Page images
PDF
EPUB

and Roman writers, uniformly decides in favour of the Roman. For the preference which he gives to Cicero, he affigns, and lays ftrefs on one reafon of a pretty extraordinary nature; viz. that Demofthenes could not poffibly have fo complete an infight as Cicero into the manners and paffions of men; Why ?-Because he had not the advantage of perufing Ariftotle's treatife of Rhetoric, wherein, fays our critic, he has fully laid open that mystery; and, to fupport this weighty argument, he enters. into a controverfy with A. Gellius, in order to prove that Ariftotle's Rhetoric was not published till after Demofthenes had spoken, at least, his moft confiderable orations. Nothing can be more childish. Such orators as Cicero and Demofthenes, derived their knowledge of the human paffions and their power of moving them, from higher fources than any treatife of rhetoric. One French critic has indeed departed from the common track; and, after beftowing on Cicero thofe juft praifes, to which the confent of fo many ages fhews him to be entitled, concludes, however, with giving the palm to Demofthenes. This is Fenelon, the famous archbishop of Cambray, and author of Telemachus; himself, furely, no enemy to all the graces and flowers of compofition. It is in his Reflections on Rhetoric and Poetry, that he gives this judgment; a fmall tract, commonly published along with his Dialogues on Eloquence *. Thefe dialogues and reflections are particularly worthy of perufal, as containing, I think,

*As his expreffions are remarkably happy and beautiful, the paffage here referred to deferves to be inferted. Je ne crains pas dire, que Demofthene me parot fupérieur a Cice"ron. Je protefte que perfonne n'admire plús "Cicéron que je fais. Il embellit tout ce qu'il "touche. Il fait honneur à la parole. Il fait "des mots ce qu'un autre n'en fauroit faire. I

[ocr errors]

je ne fai combien de fortes d'efprits. Il eft "même court, & vehement, toutes les fois qu'il "veut l'eftre'; contre Catiline, contre Verres, contre Antoine. Mais on remarque quelque parure dans fons difcours. L'art y eft merveilleux; mais on l'entrevoit. L'orateur en pen"fant au falut de la république, ne s'oublie pas. et ne fe laiffe pas oublier. Demofthene papa ❝roit fortir de foi, et ne voir que la patrie. Il ne cherche point le heau; il le fait, fans y "penfer. Il eft au-deffus de l'admiration. 11 fe "fert de la parole, comme un homme modefte de fon habit, pour fe couvrir. Il tonne; il foudroye. C'est un torrent qui entraine tout. "On ne peut le critiquer, parcequ'on eft faifi. On penfe aux chofer dit, & non à fes pa

[ocr errors]

:

[merged small][ocr errors][merged small][ocr errors][merged small]

pre

Scribendi rectè, fapere eft & principium & fons,
Good fenfe and knowledge are the foun-
dation of all good fpeaking. There is no
art that can teach one to be eloquent, in
any fphere, without a fufficient acquaint-
ance with what belongs to that sphere; or
if there were an art that made fuch
tenfions, it would be mere quackery, like
the pretenfions of the fophifts of old, to
teach their difciples to speak for and against
every fubject; and would be defervedly
Attention to
exploded by all wife men.
ftyle, to compofition, and all the arts of
fpeech, can only aflift an orator in fetting
off, to advantage, the ftock of materials
which he poffeffes; but the stock, the ma-
terials themselves, must be brought from
other quarters than from rhetoric. He who
is to plead at the bar, must make himself
thoroughly mafter of the knowledge of the
law; of all the learning and experience
that can be useful in his profeffion, for fup-
porting a caufe, or convincing a judge.
He who is to fpeak from the pulpit, mult
apply himself closely to the study of divi
nity, of practical religion, of morals, of hu-
the topics both of inftruction and of per-
man nature; that he may be rich in all
fuafion. He who would fit himself for be-
ing a member of the fupreme council of
the nation, or of any public affembly, muft
be thoroughly acquainted with the bufinefs
that belongs to fuch affembly; he must

"roles. On le perd de vue. On n'eft occupé

[ocr errors]

que de Philippe qui envahit tout. Je fuis "charme de ces deux orateurs: mais j'avoue que "je fuis moins touché de l'art infini, & de la "magnifique éloquence de Cicéron, que de la "rapide fimplicité de Demofthene." 6

ftudy

ftudy the forms of court, the courfe of procedure; and muft attend minutely to all the facts that may be the fubject of queftion or deliberation.

Befides the knowledge that properly belongs to that profeffion to which he addicts himself, a public fpeaker, if ever he expects to be eminent, must make himself acquainted, as far as his neceffary occupa tions allow, with the general circle of polite literature. The study of poetry may be useful to him on many occafions, for embellishing his ftyle, for fuggefting lively images, or agreeable allufions. The study of history may be still more useful to him; as the knowledge of facts, of eminent characters, and of the course of human affairs, finds place on many occafions. There are few great occafions of public fpeaking, in which one will not derive affiftance from cultivated tafte, and extenfive knowledge., They will often yield him materials for proper ornament; fometimes, for argument and real use. A deficiency of knowledge, even in fubjects that belong not directly to his own profeflion, will expose him to many difadvantages, and give better qualified rivals a great fuperiority over him. Blair.

$75. A Habit of Industry recommended to

the intended Speaker.

Allow me to recommend, in the third place, not only the attainment of useful knowledge, but a habit of application and industry. Without this, it is impoffible to excel in any thing. We must not imagine that it is by a fort of mushroom growth, that one can rife to be a diftinguished pleader, or preacher, or fpeaker in any affembly. It is not by ftarts of application, or by a few years preparation of tudy afterwards difcontinued, that eminence can be attained. No; it can be attained only by means of regular industry, grown up into a habit, and ready to be exerted on every occafion that calls for industry. This is the fixed law of our nature; and he must have a very high opinion of his own genius indeed, that can believe himself an exception to it. A very

[ocr errors][merged small]
[ocr errors]

wife law of our nature it is; for industry is, in truth, the great "Condimentum, the feafoning of every pleasure; without which life is doomed to languish. Nothing is fo great an enemy both to honourable attainments, and to the real, to the brifk, and fpirited enjoyment of life, as that relaxed ftate of mind which arifes from indelence and diffipation. One that is deftined to excel in any art, especially in the arts of speaking and writing, will be known by this more than by any other mark whatever, an enthufiafm for that art; an enthusiasm, which, firing his mind with the object he has in view, will difpofe him to relish every labour which the means require. It was this that characterised the great men of antiquity; it is this, which muft diftinguish the moderns who would tread their fteps. This honourable enthufiafm, it is highly neceffary for fuch as are ftudying oratory to cultivate. If youth wants it, manhood will flag miferably.

Ibid.

§ 76. Attention to the best Models recom

mended to the Student in Eloquence. Attention to the beft models will contribute greatly towards improvement. Every one who speaks or writes fhould, indeed, endeavour to have fomewhat that is his own, that is peculiar to himself, and that characterifes his compofition and style. Slavifh imitation depreffes genius, or rather betrays the want of it. But withal, there is no genius fo original, but may be profited and affifted by the aid of proper examples, in ftyle, compofition, and delivery. They always open some new ideas; they ferve to enlarge and correct our own. They quicken the current of thought, and excite emulation. Ibid.

$77. Caution necessary in choofing Models.

Much, indeed, will depend upon the right choice of models which we purpose to imitate; and fuppofing them rightly chofen, a farther care is requifite, of not being feduced by a blind univerfal admiration. For, "decipit exemplar, vitiis imi"tabile." Even in the most finished models we can felect, it must not be forgotten, that there are always fome things improper for imitation. We fhould study to acquire a juft conception of the peculiar characteristic beauties of any writer, or public fpeaker, and imitate these only. One

ought

[blocks in formation]

§ 78. On the Style of BOLINGBROKE and SWIFT.

Some authors there are, whofe manner of writing approaches nearer to the ftyle of fpeaking than others; and who, therefore, can be imitated with more fafety. In this clafs, among the English authors, are Dean Swift, and Lord Bolingbroke. The Dean, throughout all his writings, in the midst of much correctness, maintains the eafy natural manner of an unaffected fpeaker; and this is one of his chief excellencies. Lord Bolingbroke's ftyle is more fplendid, and more declamatory than Dean Swift's; but ftill it is the style of one who speaks, or rather who harangues. Indeed, all his political writings (for it is to them only, and not to his philofophical ones, that this obfervation can be applied) carry much more the appearance of one declaiming with warmth in a great affembly, than of one writing in a closet, in order to be read by others. They have all the copioufnefs, the fervour, the inculcating method, that is allowable and graceful in an orator; perhaps too much of it for a writer: and it is to be regretted, as I have formerly obferved, that the matter contained in them fhould have been fo trivial or fo false; for, from the manner and ftyle, confiderable advantage might be reaped.

Ibid.

$79. Frequent Exercise in compofing and Speaking neceffary for Improvement in Eloquence.

Befides attention to the best models, frequent exercife, both in compofing and fpeaking, will be admitted to be a neceffary mean of improvement. That fort of compofition is, doubtless, most useful, which relates to the profeffion, or kind of public speaking, to which perfons addict themselves. This they fhould keep ever in their eye, and be gradually inuring themselves to it. But let me also advise them, not to allow themselves in negligent compofition of any kind. He who has it for his aim to write, or to fpeak correctly, fhould, in the most trivial kind of compofition, in writing a letter, nay, even in

[ocr errors]

common discourse, study to acquit himself. with propriety. I do not at all mean, that he is never to write, or to speak a word, but in elaborate and artificial language. This would form him to a stiffness and affectation, worse, by ten thousand degrees, than the greatest negligence. But it is to be observed, that there is, in every thing, a manner which is becoming, and has propriety; and oppofite to it, there is a clumfy and faulty performance of the fame thing. The becoming manner is very of ten the moft light, and feemingly careless manner; but it requires tafte and attention to feize the juft idea of it. That idea, when acquired, we should keep in our eye, and form upon it whatever we write or Ibid. fay.

[blocks in formation]

It now only remains to enquire, of what ufe may the ftudy of critical and rhetorical writers be, for improving one in the practice of eloquence? Thefe are certainly not to be neglected; and yet, I dare not fay that much is to be expected from them. For profeffed writers on public fpeaking, we must look chiefly among the ancients. In modern times, for reafons which were before given, popular eloquence, as an art, has never been very much the object of ftudy; it has not the fame powerful effect among us that it had in more democratical ftates; and therefore has not been cultiAmong the vated with the fame care. moderns, though there has been a great deal of good criticism on the different kinds of writing, yet much has not been attempted on the fubject of eloquence, or public difcourfe; and what has been given us of that kind has been drawn moftly from the ancients. Such a writer as Joannes Gerardus Voffius, who has gathered into one heap of pondrous lumber, all the trifling, as well as the useful things, that are to be found in the Greek and Roman writers, is enough to disgust one with the study of eloquence. Among the French, there has been more attempted, on this fubject, than among the English. The Bishop of Cambray's writings on eloquence, I before mentioned with honour. Rollin, Batteux, Crevier, Gibert, and feveral other French critics, have alfo written on oratory; but though fome of them may be useful, none of them are fo confiderable as to deserve particular recommendation.

Ibid.

[ocr errors]

learned from it; and it is no small, benefi

§ 81. Recourse must chiefly be had to the to be made acquainted with Cicero's own

original Writers.

It is to the original ancient writers that we must chiefly have recourfe; and it is a reproach to any one, whofe profeffion calls him to fpeak in public, to be unacquainted with them. In all the ancient rhetorical writers, there is, indeed, this defect, that they are too fyftematical, as I formerly fhewed; they aim at doing too much; at reducing rhetoric to a complete and perfect art, which may even fupply invention with materials on every subject; infomuch that one would imagine they expected to form an orator by rule, in as mechanical a manner as one would form a carpenter. Whereas, all that can in truth be done, is to give openings for affifting and enlightening tafte, and for pointing out to genius the courfe it ought to hold.

Ariftotle laid the foundation for all that was afterwards written on the fubject. That amazing and comprehenfive genius, which does honour to human nature, and which gave light into fo many different sciences, has inveftigated the principles of rhetoric with great penetration. Ariftotle appears to have been the first who took rhetoric out of the hands of the fophifts, and introduced reasoning and good fense into the art. Some of the profoundeft things which have been written on the paffions and manners of men, are to be found in his Treatife on Rhetoric; though in this, as in all his writings, his great brevity often renders him obfcure. Succeeding Greek rhetoricians, moft of whom are now loft, improved on the foundation which Ariftotle had laid. Two of them ftill remain, Demetrius Phalerius, and Dionyfius of Halicarnaffus; both write on the construction of fentences, and deferve to be perused; efpecially Dionyfius, who is a very accurate and judicious critic.

I need fcarcely recommend the rhetorical writings of Cicero. Whatever, on the fubject of eloquence, comes from fo great an orator, must be worthy of attention. His moft confiderable work on this fubject is that De Oratore, in three books. None of Cicero's writings are more highly finished than this treatife. The dialogue is polite; the characters are well supported, and the conduct of the whole is beautiful and agreeable. It is, indeed, full of digreffions, and his rules and obfervations may be thought fometimes too vague and general. Ufeful things, however, may be

idea of eloquence. The "Orator ad M. "Brutum," is also a confiderable treatise; and, in general, throughout all Cicero's rhetorical works there run those high and fublime ideas of eloquence, which are fitted both for forming a just taste, and for creating that enthusiasm for the art, which is of the greatest consequence for excelling in it.

But, of all the antient writers on the fubject of oratory, the most inftructive, and moft useful, is Quinctilian. I know few books which abound more with good sense, and discover a greater degree of juft and accurate tafte, than Quinctilian's Inftitu tions. Almost all the principles of good criticifm are to be found in them. He has digefted into excellent order all the ancient ideas concerning rhetoric, and is, at the fame time, himself an eloquent writer. Though fome parts of his work contain too much of the technical and artificial fyftem then in vogue, and for that reafon may be thought dry and tedious, yet I would not advise the omitting to read any part of his Inftitutions. To pleaders. at the bar, even these technical parts may prove of fome ufe. Seldom has any perfon, of more found and diftinct judgment than Quinctilian, applied himself to the ftudy of the art of oratory. Blair.

§ 82. On the Neceffity of a Claffical Edu

cation.

In fome

The fairest diamonds are rough till they are polifhed, and the pureft gold must be run and washed, and fifted in the ore. We are untaught by nature; and the finest qualities will grow wild and degenerate, if the mind is not formed by difcipline, and cultivated with an early care. perfons, who have run up to men without a liberal education, we may obferve many great qualities darkened and eclipfed; their minds are crufted over like diamonds in the rock, they flash out fometimes into an irregular greatness of thought, and betray in their actions an unguided force, and unmanaged virtue; fomething very great and very noble may be difcerned, but it looks cumbersome and awkward, and is alone of all things the worfe for being natural. Nature is undoubtedly the best miftrefs and apteft fcholar; but nature herself must be civilized, or fhe will look favage, as fhe appears in the Indian princes, who are vefted with a native majefty, a fur

prifing

prifing greatness and generofity of foul, and difcover what we always regret, fine parts, and excellent natural endowments, without improvement. In thofe countries, which we call barbarous, where art and politeness are not understood, nature hath the greater advantage in this, that fimplicity of manners often fecures the innocence of the mind; and as virtue is not, fo neither is vice, civilized and refined; but in these politer parts of the world, where virtue excels by rules and difcipline, vice alfo is more inftructed, and with us good qualities will not fpring up alone: many hurtful weeds will rife with them, and choak them in their growth, unless removed by fome skilful hand; nor will the mind be brought to a juft perfection without cherishing every hopeful feed, and repreffing every fuperfluous humour: the mind is like the body in this regard, which cannot fall into a decent and eafy carriage, unless it be fashioned in time: an untaught behaviour is like the people that use it, truly ruftic, forced and uncouth, and art must be applied to make it natural.

Felton.

$83. On the Entrance to Knowledge. Knowledge will not be won without pains and application: fome parts of it are eafier, fome more difficult of accefs: we muft proceed at once by fap and battery; and when the breach is practicable, you have nothing to do, but to prefs boldly on, and enter: it is troublesome and deep digging for pure waters, but when once you come to the spring, they rife and meet you the entrance into knowledge is oftentimes very narrow, dark and tirefome, but the rooms are spacious, and gloriously furnished the country is admirable, and every profpect entertaining. You need not wonder, that fine countries have ftrait avenues, when the regions of happiness, like thofe of knowledge, are impervious, and fhut to lazy travellers, and the way to heaven itself is narrow.

Common things are eafily attained, and no body values what lies in every body's way: what is excellent is placed out of ordinary reach, and you will eafily be perfuaded to put forth your hand to the utmost ftretch, and reach whatever you aspire at.

Ibid.

584. Claffics recommended. Many are the fubjects which will invite and deferve the steadieft application from

thofe who would excel, and be distinguished in them. Human learning in general; natural philofophy, mathematics, and the whole circle of fcience. But there is no neceffity of leading you through these feveral fields of knowledge; it will be most commendable for you to gather fome of the fairest fruit from them all, and to lay up a store of good sense, and found reason, of great probity, and folid virtue. This is the true ufe of knowledge, to make it fubfervient to the great duties of our most holy religion, that as you are daily grounded in the true and faving knowledge of a Chriftian, you may use the helps of human learning, and direct them to their proper end. You will meet with great and wonderful examples of an irregular and mistaken virtue in the Greeks and Romans, with many inftances of greatness of mind, of unfhaken fidelity, contempt of human grandeur, a moft paffionate love of their country, prodigality of life, difdain of fervitude, inviolable truth, and the most public difinterested fouls, that ever threw off all regards in comparison with their country's good: you will difcern the flaws and blemishes of their faireft actions, fee the wrong apprehenfions they had of virtue, and be able to point them right, and keep them within their proper bounds. Under this correction you may extract a generous and noble fpirit from the writings and hiftories of the ancients. And I would in a particular manner recommend the claflic authors to your favour, and they will recommend themfelves to your approbation.

If you would refolve to mafter the Greek as well as the Latin tongue, you will find, that the one is the fource and original of all that is most excellent in the other: I do not mean fo much for expreffion, as thought, though fome of the most beautiful ftrokes of the Latin tongue are drawn from the lines of the Grecian orators and poets; but for thought and fancy, for the very foundation and embellishment of their works, you will fee, the Latins have ranfacked the Grecian ftore, and, as Horace adviles all who would fucceed in writing well, had their authors night and morning in their hands.

And they have been fuch happy imitators, that the copies have proved more exact than the originals; and Rome has triumphed over Athens, as well in wit as arms; for though Greece may have the honour of invention, yet it is eafier to ftrike out a new courfe of thought

than

« PreviousContinue »