Making Difference in Medieval and Early Modern IberiaUniversity of Notre Dame Press, 2005 - 218 pages In this engaging study Jean Dangler examines the way that ideas of difference were forged in four types of medieval Iberian discourse: muwashshah/jarcha poems from al-Andalus, Andalusi "cutting poems," medical literature about the body, and portrayals of the monster. According to Dangler, these texts demonstrate the two fundamental precepts of medieval Iberian alterity: multifaceted subject formation and the embrace of contrasts and the negative. Medieval Iberia was a multicultural territory of Muslim, Jewish, and Christian societies. These communities had constant geographic, cultural, political, and economic contact with one another. Because medieval Iberia was not hierarchical and homogenous, medieval subjectivity was not always marked by essential qualities of character, but was mutable and shifting. The adverse was often esteemed in the making of meaning and the forging of the social order. Dangler explores how the four discourses she analyzes changed in the early modern period, from an acceptance of difference to more rigid concepts of subjectivity and the marginalization of difference. This shift accompanied the rise of the Castilian nation-state and its imposition of static hierarchies of value. This book will appeal to a broad range of medievalists. It makes an important contribution to the growing interest in medieval Iberia and offers a nuanced understanding of medieval history and culture in general. |
From inside the book
Results 1-3 of 54
... contrasts and the negative eroded throughout the later Middle Ages , as did the complementary worth of the via negativa and ... contrast to the affirma- tive , but was a threat to be extinguished . Division became a mechanism to create ...
... contrast to this view , the frequent fluidity of medieval lyric may be due to its lack of fixity in an originating person , place , or source , and not to its requisite association with an individual poet . This is evident in the many ...
... contrast , which he called " the affinity of contraries " ( " shiddat i'tilaf fi shiddat ikhtilaf " ) . 15 Al - Jahiz initiated a literary debate genre on contrasts in which he eluci- dated the attributes and shortcomings of a thing ...